Law & Justice
Gurpatwant Singh Pannun to Face Nikhil Gupta in New York Sentencing Hearing
By Divya A

Khalistani separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun and Indian national Nikhil Gupta, accused of conspiring to assassinate Pannun in New York in 2023, are expected to meet for the first time on November 20 when Pannun appears in person at a U.S. court for Gupta’s sentencing hearing. Both are likely to make oral submissions during the proceeding. U.S. prosecutors have asked the district judge to grant Pannun 20 minutes as a “victim‑witness,” while Gupta’s New York‑based counsel, Isabelle A. Kirshner, told The Indian Express that defendants also have the right to address the court orally. “Under the law, all defendants have the right to address the court orally and in connection with our sentencing submission. ‘Victims’ of crimes also have the right to speak at sentencing proceedings,” Kirshner said.
Gupta, charged with murder‑for‑hire, conspiracy to commit murder‑for‑hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering in the failed 2023 assassination plot, has been held in Brooklyn since his extradition from the Czech Republic in June 2024. After initially pleading not guilty, he admitted guilt in February, shifting the case from allegations to an admission by an Indian citizen of involvement in an assassination plot on foreign soil. Prosecutors are seeking a 24‑year sentence; Gupta’s counsel has requested 12 years and submitted a remorse letter to U.S. District Judge Victor Marrero. In his sentencing submission, Gupta expressed deep regret and stated that he acted alone.
Pannun has also filed a civil lawsuit naming the Government of India, National Security Advisor Ajit Doval, and former Research and Analysis Wing chief Samant Goel, alleging a conspiracy to kill him. The U.S. federal court has ordered summonses to be served through Delhi courts in connection with the lawsuit. New Delhi has repeatedly denied any involvement in a plot against Pannun, stating that the Indian government never engages in such acts. Kirshner noted that the civil lawsuit will not affect the criminal sentencing proceedings.
An order dated November 13 directed the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York to send the summonses and accompanying documents to the Patiala House District Court for Doval and the Dwarka and Tis Hazari courts for Goel. Judge Katherine Polk Failla requested the assistance of Indian courts to effect service of process on the defendants in the civil action pending before the U.S. court. India has rejected the lawsuit as “frivolous,” with External Affairs Ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal stating that such requests can only be routed through India’s Ministry of Law and Justice.
Frequently asked questions
When will Gurpatwant Singh Pannun appear in person at the sentencing hearing?
He is expected to appear on November 20.
What charges are brought against Nikhil Gupta?
He is charged with murder‑for‑hire, conspiracy to commit murder‑for‑hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering in the failed 2023 assassination plot.