Law & Justice

81‑Year‑Old Convicted of 1966 Illinois Murder After DNA Reopens Cold Case

By

81‑Year‑Old Convicted of 1966 Illinois Murder After DNA Reopens Cold Case
Photo: How to create GTA 6-style AI photos using Gemini and ChatGPT: Try these 5 easy prompts for Instagram-worthy images

In November 1966, 18‑year‑old Karen Snider was stabbed more than 120 times in her Calumet City, Illinois, home while her two‑month‑old daughter slept nearby. The killer was never charged at the time. Nearly 60 years later, James Barbier, a former family friend who had helped carry Karen’s coffin at her funeral, was found guilty of first‑degree murder. A jury convicted him on November 9, 2026, when he was 81. The conviction followed a renewed investigation that used DNA testing of evidence from the crime scene to identify Barbier as the suspect. He had been arrested shortly after the killing but was never charged. During the trial, Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney Krystyn Dilillo explained that Barbier was friends with both Karen and her husband, Paul, and that he knew Paul’s work schedule. Karen had allowed Barbier into the house, after which he attacked her with a weapon, stabbing her 125 times, including in the neck and chest. The injuries also affected her heart, liver and lungs. An autopsy revealed defensive wounds on Karen’s hands, indicating she had tried to resist. Paul returned from work at about 11 p.m. and found Karen dead; their infant daughter had been sleeping in a bassinet nearby. Police had originally suspected Barbier after noticing blood spatter near a broken basement window and observing that he returned home that night appearing nervous, with cuts and blood on him. He was arrested in 1966 but not charged, and he later served as a pallbearer at Karen’s funeral. The case remained cold until 2022, when a tip from Kevin Seeley prompted investigators to reopen the file. New DNA testing linked Barbier to blood stains on his trousers and Karen’s dress. Barbier, who had moved to Missouri, was arrested at his home in Creve Coeur in 2024 and eventually tried and convicted in 2026. Karen’s daughter, Paula Larson, who was only two months old when her mother was killed, grew up without her and learned about the circumstances of her death from her father, who died in 1989. After the verdict, Larson expressed relief at the conviction and hope that Barbier would never be released from prison. Barbier is scheduled to be sentenced on December 15, 2026. The conviction ends a criminal case that had remained unresolved since 1966 and provides long‑awaited answers for Karen’s family.

Related stories