Law & Justice
Supreme Court Bars Banks From Forcing Homebuyers to Repay Loans Until Bank‑Builder Link Is Proven

In a decision that could spare hundreds of thousands of homebuyers, the Supreme Court ruled that the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) or the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) cannot order flat buyers to repay a financier unless the court first examines the relationship between the bank and the builder. The order, issued by a bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant and joined by Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, was taken on a petition filed by buyers of the Krishna housing project in Gurgaon, developed by Raheja Developers, which has entered insolvency proceedings.
The petitioners had been sued by the bank in a commercial court in Saket, New Delhi, even though they had not yet received their flats. The Supreme Court held that it is the court’s duty to determine whether the bank’s disbursement of loan funds to the builder complied with the tripartite agreement that requires the financier to pay the builder in proportion to construction progress. The court said that unless a clear finding is made that the homebuyers are in default, no interim direction can be issued for payment of instalments.
The court directed the civil court not to take any coercive action against the petitioners or other similarly situated buyers until the bank‑builder nexus is established.
Under the tripartite agreement, the financier is supposed to disburse the loan directly to the builder based on construction milestones. In many cases, however, banks have released loan amounts to buyers that exceed the amount that should have been paid to the builder, owing to a close relationship between bank officials and builders. When projects remain incomplete for years, banks have filed recovery suits against buyers who continue to pay EMIs and rent without receiving their flats, potentially imposing crippling financial liability.
Earlier in September, a bench led by Justice Kant ordered a CBI inquiry into alleged collusion between builders and banks across India that abused the tripartite subvention scheme and defrauded homebuyers. The Supreme Court noted that its sympathetic stance has led to a surge in litigation, with thousands of buyers seeking relief.
In a related case from Bengaluru involving more than 4,000 buyers, the court protected homebuyers from potential bank recovery actions while the project remained incomplete for nearly a decade, despite the buyers having paid 95% of the flat cost. After granting protection, the bench instructed the petitioners’ counsel to approach the Karnataka High Court for further relief.