Law & Justice
Carriage Operators Sue NYC Over New Ban, Claim Unconstitutional

A federal lawsuit filed Thursday by the Transport Workers Union Local 100 alleges that New York City’s new law banning horse‑drawn carriages is unconstitutional. The City Council passed the ban, which Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed on Thursday, and it will take effect on June 1, 2028 in all five boroughs. The law requires a “humane disposition” of the horses, prohibiting their sale for slaughter or transfer to other carriage companies. Currently, 68 horse cabs operate in Central Park, employing about 200 drivers and up to 160 horses.
The union’s class‑action complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, says the statute will “immediately cripple” carriage owners and ignores property interests and contracts. It seeks a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction to block enforcement of the law until the court decides the merits of the case and requests expedited discovery. The city’s law department said it is reviewing the case.
The legislation, known as Romanch’s Law, was passed after the death of 18‑year‑old Romanch Mahajan, who was thrown from a carriage in Central Park over the summer. The city has long tried to ban horse‑drawn carriages, a Central Park tourist staple since 1858.
The complaint notes that the new law does not provide compensation for property such as permits, licenses, stables, and horses that are now rendered “unusable.” It only mentions a potential future compensation plan, which the union says violates the Constitution’s requirement for just compensation in a taking. The law also offers vague promises about a transition plan that would provide drivers with “help” finding employment opportunities.
At the public signing ceremony, Mayor Mamdani said the city plans to release a transition plan in April. The plan would include a process for buying back medallions—operating licenses and plates—from owners, a stipend for drivers and stable hands to attend workforce training and career development classes, and career counseling and entrepreneurship support. The mayor also said the city would work directly with horse‑carriage workers to incorporate their feedback and that the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene would oversee the sale or placement of each horse as it retires.
The case is titled Chiarello v. City of New York, S.D.N.Y., 1:26‑cv‑10154, complaint 11/19/26. Advocates for Justice represents the union.
Frequently asked questions
When will the new ban on horse‑drawn carriages take effect?
The law will take effect on June 1, 2028, in all five boroughs.
What does the lawsuit claim the law will do to carriage owners?
The complaint says the statute will immediately cripple carriage owners and ignores property interests and contracts.
What transition plan does the city propose for drivers and horses?
The city plans a transition plan that includes buying back medallions, stipends for workforce training, career counseling, and entrepreneurship support, and a process for selling or placing each horse as it retires.