Law & Justice
Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rules School Board Must Have Elected Members at Tenured Teacher’s Termination Hearing

A Philadelphia teacher who was fired for refusing weekly Covid‑19 tests has won a legal battle that began during the pandemic. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled on November 17 that the School District of Philadelphia violated state law by holding the teacher’s termination hearing without any elected school board member present.
The case involves Neal Follman, a tenured teacher who had worked for the district since January 2010 and taught at Constitution High School during the 2020‑21 school year. On February 22, 2021, Superintendent William Hite announced that employees returning to in‑person learning would be required to undergo weekly Covid‑19 testing. Follman submitted a refusal and exemption request on May 7, 2021, citing concerns about the test’s emergency‑use authorization, accuracy, handling of materials and the company administering the tests. He did not complete the medical exemption justification section of the form. The district deemed his reasons insufficient and warned that disciplinary action would follow if he continued to refuse testing.
Follman’s principal, Brianna Dunn‑Robb, recommended his termination. A district hearing officer also recommended dismissal and suspension without pay. In August 2021, the school board adopted a resolution supporting the termination recommendation. Follman was then given a statement of charges and the opportunity to challenge the proposed dismissal.
He requested a hearing under Pennsylvania’s Local Agency Law. The hearing was scheduled for September 13, 2021, postponed, and eventually held by videoconference in February 2022. No elected member of the Philadelphia Board of Education attended; instead, the board appointed hearing officer Rudolph Garcia to preside. Follman argued that Pennsylvania’s Public School Code required him to be heard before the elected school board directors themselves. On August 18, 2022, the board voted 9‑0 to dismiss him, adopting the hearing officer’s findings.
The Pennsylvania Department of Education’s Secretary of Education initially upheld the dismissal, reasoning that the board could appoint a hearing officer as long as its members reviewed the findings and made an independent decision. Follman appealed.
In July 2024, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania reversed the secretary’s decision, holding that the board had not complied with the statutory procedure for dismissing a tenured teacher. The court ordered Follman’s reinstatement with back pay unless the district properly terminated his employment. The district challenged that decision before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court, in a majority opinion written by Justice David Wecht, rejected the district’s argument that the board could delegate the entire hearing to an appointed officer. Referring to Section 1127 of the Pennsylvania Public School Code, the court held that a hearing must be conducted before the board of school directors and that at least some elected board members must be present. The court also cited Section 1129, which requires the board to consider charges and testimony before voting on a dismissal. The court did not specify how many board members must attend, but ruled that a hearing with no elected directors present could not be considered a hearing “before the board of school directors.”
The ruling affirms the Commonwealth Court’s decision to reinstate Follman with back pay, unless and until the district carries out a lawful termination. The decision does not address whether Follman’s refusal to undergo Covid testing was justified; it focuses solely on the procedural requirements for dismissing a tenured teacher in Pennsylvania.
Frequently asked questions
Who is Neal Follman?
Neal Follman is a tenured teacher who taught at Constitution High School in Philadelphia and was fired for refusing weekly Covid‑19 tests.
What did the Pennsylvania Supreme Court rule regarding school board attendance?
The court held that a termination hearing for a tenured teacher must be conducted before the school board of directors and that at least some elected board members must be present.
What was the outcome for Neal Follman after the Supreme Court decision?
The court affirmed the Commonwealth Court’s decision to reinstate him with back pay unless the district properly terminates his employment.