Law & Justice

Judge Allows Trump’s Defamation Suit Against NYT and Penguin Random House to Continue

By

Judge Allows Trump’s Defamation Suit Against NYT and Penguin Random House to Continue
Photo: The New York Times and Penguin Random House have denied defaming US President Donald Trump [File: Michael M Santiago/Getty Images/AFP]

A federal judge has ruled that Donald Trump’s defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House may proceed, marking a win for Trump in his legal campaign against media outlets he claims have treated him unfairly. US District Judge Steven Merryday, appointed by former President George H.W. Bush, issued the decision in federal court in Tampa, Florida, on Thursday. Trump has filed multiple lawsuits against media companies since 2024, alleging defamation or fraudulent misrepresentation. Critics say the suits threaten free press. The case against the Times and Penguin cites a book by two NYT reporters and articles Trump describes as “false, malicious, defamatory, and disparaging,” alleging they aimed to sabotage his 2024 presidential campaign, which he won. The Times and Penguin denied defamation, arguing Trump’s claims are legally flawed and politically motivated. Representatives for the parties did not immediately respond. Judge Merryday dismissed two of Trump’s claims but found the remaining allegations plausible, noting that statements accusing Trump of “planning and perpetrating complex crimes” were based on incomplete, minimal information. The lawsuit focuses on two articles and a book that question Trump’s business origins. Trump cited 22 statements from Peter Baker’s book *For Trump, a Lifetime of Scandals Heads Toward a Moment of Judgment* and 12 from articles by Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner, covering his role in creating *The Apprentice*, his inheritance, business ventures, and upbringing in New York City. The Times and Penguin argued in a motion to dismiss that Trump failed to explain how the statements were defamatory and that they contained subjective opinions that cannot be proven true or false. This decision follows another judge’s approval of Trump’s $10 billion defamation suit against the BBC, which alleges the broadcaster deceptively edited a documentary on the January 6, 2021, riots. Trump has also refiled a $10 billion lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal and previously sought to bar CNN, MSNBC, and Politico from the White House press pool, a ban later blocked by a federal judge. The Reporters Without Borders annual press freedom tracker noted a historic low for the United States, dropping from 57th to 64th place, and described the country as experiencing a “press freedom crisis” amid Trump’s administration.

Frequently asked questions

Who is the judge that allowed Trump's lawsuit to proceed?

US District Judge Steven Merryday, appointed by former President George H.W. Bush.

Which media companies are being sued by Trump in this case?

The New York Times and Penguin Random House.

Related stories