Law & Justice
Indiana Court of Appeals Affirms Judgment Against Condo Buyer Over Unpaid HOA Fees

An Indiana Court of Appeals decision on November 19, 2026 upheld a summary judgment against Onnie James Florence Jr. for unpaid homeowners’ association fees on a condominium he purchased in 2020. Florence bought a unit at Meridian Arch Condominiums with the intention of moving in with his daughter, but he never relocated and continued to live in Illinois. He remained responsible for the monthly HOA assessments, and by May 2021 he owed $5,229.80 in unpaid assessments. The Meridian Arch Owners Association sued to foreclose on the property, and after unsuccessful personal service, the complaint was sent by certified mail to Florence’s Illinois address. His wife signed for the documents on June 15, 2021. Florence did not respond to the lawsuit or appear in court, and the association obtained a default judgment on September 28, 2021 for $9,213.50, which included unpaid assessments, late fees, collection costs and attorneys’ fees.
Florence later paid $9,489 in February 2024. The association treated the payment as a partial satisfaction of the judgment, noting that post‑judgment interest had accrued. The association informed the court that Florence still owed $1,922.84 on the principal portion of the original judgment and sought additional assessments, late fees, costs and attorneys’ fees that had accumulated after the judgment.
In November 2024 the association amended its complaint to include the additional amounts and joined CrossCountry Mortgage as a party. In September 2025 the association requested summary judgment, claiming that Florence owed $26,813.22 in unpaid assessments, late fees, costs and attorneys’ fees. Florence did not file a response to the summary‑judgment request, and the trial court granted the association’s motion on February 3, 2026.
Florence appealed, arguing that the association had not properly accounted for his payment and that he had not received a detailed accounting. The Court of Appeals found no basis to overturn the trial court’s decision. It noted that service requirements were satisfied, that Florence’s challenge to set aside the default judgment was filed too late, and that the association’s affidavit confirmed the $9,489 payment had been credited to his account. The court rejected Florence’s claim that the mortgage lender had not been included, noting that CrossCountry was later added.
The Court of Appeals affirmed the summary judgment in favor of the Meridian Arch Owners Association and remanded the case to the trial court to determine the association’s reasonable appellate attorneys’ fees. The judgment against Florence remains in effect, and the additional appellate legal fees are still to be determined.
The decision was issued as a memorandum decision under Indiana Appellate Rule 65(D) and is not binding precedent for other courts.