Law & Justice
Jersey City Woman Wins $11.25 Million After Trooper Handcuffed Her During Stroke, State Appeals

A 48‑year‑old senior marketing executive from Jersey City, Cheryl Lynn Rhines, was driving to work on October 17, 2017 when she suffered a severe stroke. While on the New Jersey Turnpike extension, she pulled over near Interstate 78 in Newark, her car hit a guardrail, and she was unable to control the vehicle. New Jersey State Police troopers arrived about 30 minutes later and found Rhines with facial droop, difficulty moving, confusion, and slurred speech. Trooper Jennifer Albuja believed she was intoxicated and took Rhines into police custody, handcuffing her and placing her in the New Jersey State Police barracks in Somerville instead of sending her to a nearby emergency stroke center. Medical personnel were called only after someone at the station noticed her condition, resulting in a delay of roughly two and a half hours. The delay prevented Rhines from receiving timely stroke treatment, causing substantial brain injury and permanent disability. She now requires ongoing assistance with daily tasks and cannot continue her professional career. Rhines sued, alleging the officers should have recognized her medical emergency and called for emergency services. An Essex County jury awarded her approximately $19.1 million in January 2025, but after reducing damages for the delay, the final judgment was about $11.25 million. Superior Court Judge Thomas Vena denied the state’s request for a new trial in April 2025, allowing the judgment to stand. In October 2025, the state filed an appeal with the Appellate Division in Trenton, arguing that Trooper Albuja acted in good faith and should be immune from liability, and requesting a new trial or a reduction in damages. The state also contends that separate damages for pain and suffering and emotional distress may have resulted in double compensation. Rhines’ attorneys maintain that the emotional trauma from being restrained and denied medical aid is distinct from the lasting effects of her brain injury. The appeals court will decide whether to uphold the original finding of liability and the award of damages.