Law & Justice
Illinois Court Upholds Order for Williamses to Move Fence

In the Ashford Farms subdivision of St. Clair County, Illinois, Vincent and Lekeisha Williams installed a fence after reporting repeated trespassing, a stolen car, and other security incidents. The couple claimed the fence helped protect vulnerable areas such as their bedroom window and an electrical box. The Ashford Farms Homeowners Association (HOA) challenged the fence’s placement, arguing it violated community covenants that require written architectural approval for fences and restrict their location and height. The HOA’s architectural committee initially rejected the Williamses’ preferred placement but later offered a compromise that would allow the fence to extend to about the middle of the house. The couple installed the fence further forward, received a compliance notice in March 2023, and failed to remove it within the 30‑day deadline. The HOA sued to enforce the restrictions.
At trial in October 2024, the Williamses presented evidence of trespassing incidents and argued that the HOA’s proposed location would not provide adequate protection. They also cited other properties with fences that appeared to violate similar rules. The HOA’s property manager testified that another homeowner with a fence in a comparable situation had been sued and told to take it down. In April 2025, the trial court ruled in favor of the HOA, ordering the Williamses to relocate the fence to the previously approved position within 120 days and denying the HOA attorney fees.
The Williamses appealed, claiming their fence met subdivision restrictions, that the HOA was selectively enforcing rules, and that the architectural committee had not responded within the required 60‑day period. The Fifth District Appellate Court of Illinois denied the appeal on November 17, 2026, affirming the lower court’s judgment. The appellate judges held that the couple still needed architectural approval even though the fence did not reach the street. They noted the committee had approved a fence halfway along the house but not at the front. The court found insufficient evidence of selective enforcement and declined to consider the 60‑day approval argument because it was not raised in the original trial. The ruling requires the Williamses to move the fence to the position approved by the HOA.
The decision underscores the authority of homeowners associations to enforce architectural covenants and the necessity for homeowners to obtain proper approval before installing fences or making other exterior changes.
Frequently asked questions
What did the appellate court decide regarding the Williamses' fence?
The Fifth District Appellate Court of Illinois denied the Williamses' appeal on November 17, 2026, affirming the trial court’s judgment that the fence must be moved to the HOA‑approved position.
Why did the HOA challenge the fence placement?
The HOA argued the fence violated community covenants that require written architectural approval for fences and restrict their location and height.
What evidence did the Williamses present at trial?
The Williamses presented evidence of repeated trespassing incidents, a stolen car, and argued the HOA’s proposed location would not provide adequate protection; they also cited other properties with fences that appeared to violate similar rules.