Law & Justice

North Carolina Court Rejects Homeowner Lawsuit Over Kitchen Floor Dip, Citing Late Filing and Insufficient Evidence

By

North Carolina Court Rejects Homeowner Lawsuit Over Kitchen Floor Dip, Citing Late Filing and Insufficient Evidence

A North Carolina couple reported a significant dip in their new home’s kitchen floor within weeks of moving in in 2016. They notified the builder, Value Build Homes, and a representative visited to stabilize the area. The couple signed a contract with the builder on November 15, 2015, and the house received its certificate of occupancy on May 17, 2016, allowing them to move in. Within 30 to 60 days, they noticed the dip and contacted the builders, who visited and stabilized the affected area. The couple also signed an application for a builder’s limited warranty with Professional Warranty Service Corporation on October 14, 2016, which provided 10‑year coverage and required disputes to be settled through binding arbitration.

In October 2023, after consulting a crawlspace contractor, the couple expressed concern that the house had been built on an improperly sloped foundation. On November 8, 2023, Nate Holton contacted the builders, stating, “The house was never level since day 1.” The builders investigated the complaint in 2024, excavating near the foundation and taking measurements. The couple filed a lawsuit on January 17, 2025, alleging breach of contract, breach of express and implied warranties, defective construction, negligence, and unfair and deceptive trade practices.

The North Carolina Court of Appeals, in its November 18, 2026 judgment in Holton v. Value Build Homes, rejected the couple’s claims. The court held that the six‑year limitation period for defective construction claims begins at the date of substantial completion, which the court determined to be no later than May 17, 2016, the date the certificate of occupancy was issued. The builders’ later investigation in 2024 did not constitute repairs under the original construction contract, so it did not extend the limitation period. The couple had not provided evidence of a specific warranty breach or a particular obligation imposed on the builders. The warranty was administered through Professional Warranty Service Corporation, against which the couple had voluntarily dismissed their claims with prejudice in April 2026.

The court also found that the couple’s negligence claim was barred by North Carolina’s economic loss rule, as the damages sought were the same financial losses that could be claimed under the construction contract. The unfair and deceptive trade practices claim was rejected because the couple had not shown a separate financial loss caused by alleged deception.

The ruling does not determine whether the house had construction defects; it simply concludes that the couple’s claims could not proceed because they were filed outside the applicable limitation periods and lacked sufficient evidence to support the remaining allegations.

Frequently asked questions

What was the main reason the court dismissed the homeowner lawsuit?

The court held that the six‑year limitation period for defective construction claims began at the date of substantial completion (May 17, 2016) and that the couple filed outside that period, lacking evidence of a specific warranty breach.

What warranty did the couple sign and what does it cover?

They signed a builder’s limited warranty with Professional Warranty Service Corporation on October 14, 2016, which provides 10‑year coverage and requires disputes to be settled through binding arbitration.

Why was the couple’s negligence claim dismissed?

The court found it barred by North Carolina’s economic loss rule because the damages sought were the same financial losses that could be claimed under the construction contract.

Related stories