Law & Justice

Bombay High Court Orders Bank of Baroda to Preserve Documents in $15 Billion NMC Healthcare Lawsuit

By

Bombay High Court Orders Bank of Baroda to Preserve Documents in $15 Billion NMC Healthcare Lawsuit
Photo: Shetty has alleged that officials at Bank of Baroda's Abu Dhabi branch helped former NMC Healthcare executives transfer funds out of the healthcare group. ( Reuters )

The Bombay High Court on Thursday directed Bank of Baroda to keep the documents requested by Bavaguthu Raghuram Shetty in his $15 billion lawsuit against the lender in a status‑quo position. Shetty, the founder of NMC Healthcare and UAE Exchange, has accused the bank and its officials of aiding former NMC executives in moving money out of the group. He seeks access to records that he believes could show the bank’s involvement in the alleged fraud.

Shetty’s counsel asked the court for immediate inspection of the bank’s records, including loan guarantees, arguing that they could establish the lender’s role in the transactions. The bank assured the court that the records would be preserved without alteration until the next hearing on 17 December. Senior counsel Birendra Saraf, appearing for the bank, said there was no reason to believe that records would be destroyed and noted that proceedings relating to NMC were also taking place in Abu Dhabi.

Shetty’s counsel also claimed that the “massive” amount of funds transferred from NMC Healthcare was impossible without the involvement of Bank of Baroda’s Abu Dhabi branch. He noted that the bank’s system had generated around 150 alerts for suspicious transactions, all of which were closed without investigation.

After hearing both sides, a single‑judge bench of Justice Arif S. Doctor declined immediate disclosure of the documents and ordered that the status‑quo be maintained over the documents listed in Shetty’s application.

On 29 October, Shetty filed two interim applications in the Bombay High Court. The first requested court‑monitored forensic preservation of electronic records and disclosure of relevant bank records, including electronic communications, transaction data, emails and records from banking and payment systems. He also asked the court to appoint a commissioner to inspect and preserve these records. In his second application, Shetty sought an order directing the bank to furnish the security amount he has claimed, or any such amount as fixed by the court, and to set it aside in a reserve that would not be available for distribution.

Shetty’s suit names former NMC executives, including Prasanth Manghat and Promoth Manghat, among 26 defendants, and seeks $15 billion in damages, including compensation for financial losses and reputational damage, plus 18% annual interest. NMC Healthcare, once one of the largest private healthcare providers in the UAE, was listed on the London Stock Exchange before entering insolvency proceedings in 2020.

Related stories