Law & Justice
CJI Withdraws Two Cases to Avoid Religious Controversy

In New Delhi, Chief Justice Surya Kant withdrew two cases from the bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah. The bench had expanded individual incidents of lapses by authorities into nationwide judicial actions. The withdrawal was intended to prevent a potential religious controversy.
The bench’s August 4 order directed all states and union territories to remove stray animals from public places. The order drew criticism because most strays are cows and calves. A resident of Uttar Pradesh filed an application before the bench, arguing that the order could lead to cows and their progeny being rounded up, transported or disposed of without regard to the constitutional protection they enjoy. The applicant said that cows have been revered in Indian society as “gaumata” and that religious sentiments, especially among Hindus, are hurt when cows are slaughtered or mistreated. He warned that a blanket order could result in stray cattle being moved across state borders, herded into inadequate holding pens, or otherwise subjected to conditions violating the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960, rather than being rehabilitated through properly funded and regulated gaushalas.
Chief Justice Kant’s decision to withdraw the cases was supported by the four most senior Supreme Court judges. They felt it was impermissible for a bench not assigned the PIL roster to create PIL jurisdiction for itself by expanding individual cases into nationwide exercises, a violation of case‑distribution discipline that falls under the CJI’s domain. Supreme Court sources said the CJI informed the senior judges that a general survey of cases would be conducted before other benches to identify matters where the ambit had been expanded to give them a pan‑India texture by converting them into PILs. A decision on allocation to appropriate benches would be taken after that.
One of the cases, Loganathan vs State of Tamil Nadu, began with the illegal construction of a ground plus one floor without a sanctioned plan and the failure of authorities to notice it. The bench led by Justice Amanullah on March 25 said, “It is evident there are apparent widespread and blatant violations of building bylaws and land‑use regulations. In view of the above, we deem it appropriate to examine the issue on a pan‑India basis.” It impleaded municipal corporations and municipalities of the capital cities of all states and union territories.
Frequently asked questions
Why did Chief Justice Surya Kant withdraw the two cases?
He withdrew them to avoid potential religious controversy and because the bench had expanded individual incidents into nationwide PILs, violating case‑distribution discipline.
What was the August 4 order about?
The order directed all states and union territories to remove stray animals from public places.
What concerns were raised about the stray animal order?
It could lead to cows and calves being rounded up, transported, or disposed of without regard to constitutional protection and could violate the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960.