Law & Justice
Newmans File Lawsuit Over Unpaid Settlement for Unbuilt Fence

Homeowners Lisa and Michael Newman have filed a new lawsuit this autumn against the Nazcr Trac Homeowners Association and 55 neighbors who have not paid their share of a previous settlement. The suit follows the couple’s earlier legal battle, which began after the HOA refused to allow them to build a backyard fence for their five children with special needs. The original case ended with the HOA agreeing to pay the Newmans $200,000, with each subdivision homeowner expected to contribute $1,350. Sixty‑nine homeowners paid their portion, but many others did not. Some residents were unaware of the dispute until the settlement was announced and felt the decision was made without their input. The Newmans’ attorney, Victoria Davis Dávila, says the remaining homeowners still owe money and that the association could be held liable if the balance remains unpaid. The HOA is preparing a response to the new complaint, due this week. The Newmans want the matter resolved, but the unbuilt fence remains at the center of a neighborhood divided over who should pay for it.
Frequently asked questions
What was the original settlement amount awarded to the Newmans?
The HOA agreed to pay the Newmans $200,000.
How much does each subdivision homeowner owe toward the settlement?
$1,350 per homeowner.
How many homeowners have paid their portion of the settlement?
Sixty‑nine homeowners paid their portion.