Law & Justice
Federal Indictment Accuses West Virginia Auditor of Overruling Staff to Transfer Properties to Friend

A federal grand jury has indicted West Virginia State Auditor Mark A. Hunt, 66, on nine counts of theft of property for allegedly using his office to help a longtime friend and business associate obtain nine tax‑delinquent properties. Hunt is charged with overriding objections from his Land Division staff, who said the transfers were not legally permitted. The indictment also names two senior officials from the auditor’s office and a state employee in separate allegations involving falsified government timecards and bank fraud.
The nine properties, located in Kanawha and Boone counties, were sought by a business entity linked to Robert Lisle Johns, 66, described by prosecutors as Hunt’s longtime friend and business associate. Auditors in the Land Division determined that all nine properties were ineligible for deed issuance because the purchaser had failed to make the required payments and submit paperwork within statutory deadlines. Prosecutors allege Hunt proceeded despite these objections. He personally signed deeds for eight properties on March 28 of last year and the ninth on June 6. Hunt took office in January of that year.
According to the indictment, Hunt was assisted by David Keith Cole, the deputy chief of staff in the auditor’s office, and Frederic Scott Caudill, its general counsel. Johns was appointed special counsel to the office in June 2025. The four men are alleged to have been involved in the issuance of the deeds, resulting in the properties being taken from their lawful owners.
In a separate bank fraud case, the grand jury indicted Hunt and Cole alongside Marie Ann Hoffmann, 66, an employee of the state auditor’s office. Prosecutors say Hoffmann submitted falsified government timecards that included hours she spent working at Hunt’s private law firm, Mark A. Hunt & Associates. The alleged arrangement ran from May 5 to at least September 29 of this year. Hoffmann was a full‑time state employee who left her government duty station on Friday afternoons to perform paralegal and administrative work at the private firm. Hunt and Cole also frequently worked with her there during state business hours, according to the indictment. Cole approved the falsified timecards, enabling Hoffmann to receive wages from the West Virginia Treasury for work she had not performed for the state auditor’s office. Hunt was aware of the arrangement, prosecutors say.
Cole and Caudill face additional charges for making materially false statements to federal investigators during interviews concerning the disputed property deeds. Caudill allegedly made false statements during an FBI interview on October 26, including about whether he had asked staff who would act as a whistleblower over the handling of the deeds. Cole is accused of making false statements during an October 6 interview about the property transfers and his approval of Hoffmann’s timecards.
The theft charges carry a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison and a fine of up to $250,000. Making materially false statements to federal investigators carries a maximum five‑year prison term, while bank fraud carries up to 30 years in prison and a fine of up to $1 million.
West Virginia State Treasurer Larry Pack called for Hunt’s resignation following the indictment, saying the allegations required serious attention and that residents deserved transparency and accountability from elected officials.