Law & Justice

High Court Rules AI‑Generated Content Alone Does Not Constitute Forgery or Defamation

By

High Court Rules AI‑Generated Content Alone Does Not Constitute Forgery or Defamation

In a ruling from Shimla, the Himachal Pradesh High Court held that merely circulating AI‑generated videos and photographs that allegedly contain false and defamatory content does not amount to forgery under the law, and that police cannot investigate a private defamation complaint by invoking cognisable offences that are not made out. The court quashed an FIR registered against two people over Facebook posts that criticised a man and his family. Justice Rakesh Kainthla explained that defamation is a non‑cognisable offence and requires a complaint before a competent magistrate. He said that registering an FIR for cognisable offences as a pretext to investigate a non‑cognisable private dispute would defeat the legislative intent that private offences should not be investigated by police.

The court noted that the FIR did not allege that the AI‑generated videos or photographs were falsely presented as having been created by someone else, altered without lawful authority after their creation, or obtained through deception from a person unable to understand their contents. Merely claiming that the material contained false information was not sufficient to constitute forgery under Section 336(4) of the Indian Penal Code.

The case arose from a complaint that AI‑generated content circulated on Facebook defamed the complainant and his family. The videos and photographs purportedly showed him promoting the “Our Family, a Happy Family” scheme while naming his wife, nephew, relatives and friends as beneficiaries. Other posts allegedly depicted him collecting money and fleeing with it, and claimed that his sister‑in‑law had secured government employment and his brother had become a director.

Following the complaint, Ghumarwin police in Bilaspur district registered an FIR on 2 September under Sections 351(2) (criminal intimidation), 356(2) (defamation) and 336(4) (forgery to harm reputation). During the investigation, the police dropped the criminal intimidation charge and added Section 353(1)(b) (publishing or circulating false information to cause public fear or alarm). The state argued that the AI‑generated material constituted false documents and could spread hatred. Police seized mobile phones, sent the video and photographs to the state forensic science laboratory, and wrote to Facebook to identify the account from which they were uploaded.

Rejecting the state’s position, the court held that the FIR and status report did not explain how the allegations could cause public fear or alarm, or induce anyone to commit an offence against the state or public tranquillity, as required to attract Section 353(1)(b). Justice Kainthla further held that police could not investigate defamation under Section 356(2), a non‑cognisable offence, by adding other provisions that were not attracted. The court quashed the FIR and all consequential proceedings.

Frequently asked questions

What did the High Court decide about AI-generated content and forgery?

The court held that circulating AI‑generated videos and photographs that allegedly contain false and defamatory content does not amount to forgery under the law.

Why was the FIR against the two people quashed?

Because defamation is a non‑cognisable offence and the FIR did not satisfy the requirements for cognisable offences; police cannot investigate private defamation by invoking cognisable offences.

Related stories