India
Delhi High Court Orders DDA and DJB to Pay ₹11.01 Lakh to Families of Boys Who Died in 2010 Sewer Accident

The Delhi High Court on November 18 directed the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) and the Delhi Jal Board (DJB) to compensate the families of two boys who died after falling into an open sewer at a public park in Pitampura in April 2010. The court held that authorities maintaining public parks owe a heightened duty of care toward children, who cannot anticipate potential hazards as adults would. Justice Jasmeet Singh ordered each family to receive ₹11.01 lakh, plus 9% annual interest from the filing date of the petitions, and an additional ₹1 lakh each for litigation costs.
The parents of the boys, aged about 11.5 and 12.9 at the time of the accident, had sought ₹10 lakh each in compensation, arguing that the deaths resulted from gross negligence and a patent violation of law by the authorities. The DDA argued that although the park fell under its jurisdiction, the civil works were supervised by the DJB, while the DJB claimed the open sewer was protected by RCC walls 4 to 5 feet high.
The court rejected both arguments, stating that the presence of an open sewer or manhole in a public park imposes a heightened duty of care on the responsible authority. It noted that children, due to their tender age and limited foresight, may view inadequately secured pits or hazardous areas as objects of curiosity rather than threats to their lives, and therefore cannot be blamed for not recognizing or guarding against such dangers. The court concluded that the authorities failed to ensure the park was protected from untoward incidents.