India

Supreme Court Declines to Intervene in Cauvery Water Release Disputes, Cites Role of Established Authorities

By

Supreme Court Declines to Intervene in Cauvery Water Release Disputes, Cites Role of Established Authorities

A bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh ruled that the Supreme Court will not monitor or enforce the schedule for releasing Cauvery water from Karnataka to Tamil Nadu. The court said that such duties belong to the Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA) and the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC), which were created under a scheme framed pursuant to the Court’s February 16, 2018 judgment.

The bench dismissed two applications filed by Tamil Nadu that sought directions to Karnataka to make good alleged shortfalls in water releases during the current irrigation year. Justice Nath wrote that allowing the Court to intervene would effectively require it to assume the role of the very authorities entrusted with overseeing the implementation of the water‑sharing arrangement.

The judgment, pronounced on Friday and released on Saturday, noted that the CWMA, at its September 24 meeting, had found no backlog shortfall in the water releases, contrary to Tamil Nadu’s claim. The authority had directed Karnataka to maintain the stipulated daily average flows, with compliance to be monitored by the CWRC and the CWMA.

The Supreme Court’s decision follows the Court’s February 16, 2018 ruling that modified the 2007 award of the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal. To facilitate implementation, the Centre notified the Cauvery Water Management Scheme on June 1, 2018, establishing the CWMA and CWRC to oversee and regulate the water‑sharing arrangements. Under the arrangement, Karnataka is required to release 177 TMC of Cauvery water to Tamil Nadu in a normal year, with allocations to be proportionately adjusted in years of distress.

Tamil Nadu had sought directions to Karnataka to implement the CWMA’s decisions of July 30 and September 8, 2026, and to make good alleged shortfalls of 26.954 TMC and 16.01 TMC, respectively, at the inter‑state measuring station of Billigundulu. In its first application, Tamil Nadu requested the release of 3,500 cusecs for 15 days from Karnataka’s Kabini and Krishnaraja Sagara reservoirs, and directions to the CWMA to monitor reservoir flows every 10 days and ensure that the stipulated monthly and 10‑day releases were maintained. The state contended that even if Karnataka complied with the July 30 directions, a shortfall of 5.379 TMC would remain, alleging wilful non‑compliance with the CWMA’s directions.

Karnataka maintained that the initial deficit had been made good after adequate rainfall in the Wayanad region. It told the court that it had released 1,65,080 cusecs from its reservoirs and, despite a delay of two days in complying with the CWMA’s directions, subsequently achieved the prescribed releases. The state also pointed out that 86,797 cusecs had flowed at Billigundulu against the stipulated 45,500 cusecs.

The Court noted that Tamil Nadu had acknowledged Karnataka’s position in its response to the state’s affidavit and observed that the release schedule operates on an annual cycle from June to May. The Court also pointed out that both the CWMA and CWRC have representatives from Karnataka and Tamil Nadu, and that it was difficult to accept that the concerns of the lower riparian state would be disregarded by the expert bodies constituted to ensure compliance with the Court’s final judgment.

The second application concerned the CWMA’s September 8 decision directing Karnataka to ensure daily average flows of 6,000 cusecs at Billigundulu for 15 days from September 9. Tamil Nadu sought enforcement of that direction and the release of an alleged shortfall of 16.01 TMC for the period between June 1 and September 9. Karnataka disputed the allegations and maintained that it had complied with the September 8 directions, releasing water in excess of the stipulated quantity.

The Supreme Court said that an assessment of distress conditions and flows across the entire Cauvery basin, and the calculation of any accumulated shortfall, required examination by the CWRC and CWMA. The bench rejected Tamil Nadu’s contention that its grievances were not being adequately addressed by the two bodies, noting that the CWRC met every 15 days to review the prevailing situation, hear the states and issue appropriate directions.

The judgment also dismissed a separate application filed by the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK), holding that Tamil Nadu’s concerns were already adequately represented before the Court. The Court said the scope of the tribunal’s award, as affirmed and modified by the Supreme Court in 2018, could not be enlarged by entertaining claims or objections from an applicant that was not a party to the original proceedings before the tribunal.

Related stories