Politics
UK Employers Urged to Provide Feedback to Unsuccessful Applicants
By Today News Hours Editorial Desk

Employers are being urged to give interview feedback, a move highlighted in former minister Alan Milburn’s review of young people not in employment, education or training (NEETs). Milburn’s report, aimed at reducing the NEET rate from 13% to about 5% by 2036, recommends that large employers give all unsuccessful applicants under 25 "meaningful feedback". The proposals mainly apply to England, with a suggestion that Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland adapt the principles to their own systems.
Job seekers report that the lack of response, or "job ghosting", leaves them demoralised and undermines their confidence. Yugraj Samrai, 23, from Coventry, says he has submitted hundreds of applications since graduating with a marketing degree in July, but 30‑40% of the time he receives no reply. He told the BBC, "I understand there are very few graduate jobs available, but at least give me a response to say whether I’ll progress onto the next stage or not. I’ve spent all that time and energy submitting my application but got nothing in return."
Ffion Johns, 24, from Llanelli, has been unemployed since June and did not secure an interview until September after sending 70 applications. She says her biggest challenge has been not receiving feedback on why she was not selected, and she has been ghosted after interviews several times. "With most of these roles I’m not getting a rejection. I’m just not hearing anything, which can be quite frustrating," she says.
A 2023 study by head‑hunting firm Robert Walters found that 86% of UK job hunters said their applications had been ignored, with no response from the hiring organisation. The Milburn report notes that this "wall of silence" is especially hard on young people, who invest significant time and emotional energy into their applications.
Employers explain that they are flooded with applications in a competitive market and that AI is enabling candidates to submit large numbers of applications in hopes of improving their chances. Meg Burton, a career coach in Leeds, argues that firms should at least inform applicants when they are unsuccessful and that AI could help achieve this. She says candidates should receive basic feedback if they reach the interview stage, "just some pointers on why they were unsuccessful and what they can learn from that experience going forward."
The government could adopt the Milburn proposals and crack down on job ghosting, but it raises the question of whether an increase in rejections could itself be demoralising. Ellie McCrone, 20, from Northampton, understands the concern but believes hearing back and receiving constructive feedback is always best. "If you are applying for hundreds of jobs and never getting anything, I think something is going wrong… You can’t fix something unless you know what the problem is."
Applicants can improve their chances by tailoring their CVs to each job and avoiding sending identical applications in bulk. Burton advises candidates not to take ghosting personally, noting that "not hearing back does not mean you aren’t a great candidate. Put it down to experience and move on."