India

MP High Court Reinstates Police Sub‑Inspector, Criticises State’s Use of AI in Legal Drafting

By

MP High Court Reinstates Police Sub‑Inspector, Criticises State’s Use of AI in Legal Drafting

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ordered the state government to reinstate a police sub‑inspector who was dismissed within 24 hours of a sexual‑harassment complaint being filed against him in 2024. Justice Vivek Kumar Singh quashed the dismissal, ruling that the state had bypassed constitutional due process by invoking Article 311(2)(b), which allows departmental inquiries to be dispensed with only in exceptional circumstances. The court directed the government to conduct a regular departmental inquiry in accordance with the law but did not rule on the merits of the allegations.

In reviewing the state’s defence, the bench found that government counsel had cited a non‑existent Supreme Court judgment, State of Andhra Pradesh vs S.S. Mohammad Nisar (reported as (2008) 5 SCC 230), to argue that reappreciation of evidence is impermissible under Article 226. The court clarified that no such judgment exists and that the citation actually belongs to Sidhartha Vashisht alias Manu Sharma vs State (NCT of Delhi), a case unrelated to the present matter. The bench said the citation was a result of the state “blindly resorting to artificial intelligence tools” to draft pleadings, leading to the inclusion of a fabricated case name.

The court warned that inserting fictitious case law without verifying citations wastes judicial time and borders on actively misleading the court. It cautioned the Advocate General’s office to meticulously verify all legal propositions and citations before filing them.

The sub‑inspector was accused of indecent behaviour with a woman cleaner at the state situation room in Bhopal on 26 May 2024. He was suspended the same day and dismissed on 27 May without a departmental inquiry. The court found the state’s justification for invoking Article 311(2)(b) unsustainable in law. Government advocate Swati Aseem George and Advocate General Prashant Singh declined to comment.

Frequently asked questions

Why did the MP High Court quash the dismissal of the police sub‑inspector?

The court found the state had bypassed constitutional due process by invoking Article 311(2)(b) without an exceptional circumstance, so it ordered the sub‑inspector be reinstated and a regular departmental inquiry conducted.

What error did the state make in its legal pleadings?

State counsel cited a non‑existent Supreme Court judgment, mistakenly using AI‑generated references, which the court said was a fabricated case name.

Related stories