Politics
Hegseth Faces Ongoing Scrutiny After Impeachment Motion Blocked
By Hoda Sherif

A week after a failed impeachment effort, analysts say Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth remains under intense scrutiny for his leadership at the Pentagon. Following the United States midterm elections, attention has focused on whether Hegseth will retain his cabinet position once Congress’s new Democratic majorities take office. Hegseth, who was sworn in on January 25, 2025, has overseen several of President Donald Trump’s controversial international campaigns, including the war on Iran and a series of deadly boat strikes in the Caribbean Sea and eastern Pacific Ocean, both of which have been accused of violating international law.
The Iran war became a political liability for Trump’s Republican Party during the midterm race. A poll earlier this month found that 44 percent of U.S. voters said they were less likely to vote for a midterm candidate who supported the war, compared with 13 percent who said they were more inclined to vote for such a candidate, a ratio of more than three to one. The Democratic Party won a decisive victory in the November 3 midterms, flipping both the House of Representatives and the Senate from Republican control.
Less than a week later, Hegseth faced a push for impeachment led by outgoing Republican Congressman Thomas Massie. Massie filed eight articles of impeachment, accusing Hegseth of dismantling safeguards that protected civilian lives, leading to incidents such as the bombing of an elementary school in Minab, Iran, that killed at least 120 children. The impeachment proceedings were shelved on November 10 after the Republicans’ lame‑duck majority in the House voted 211 to 204 to block the measure; eleven Democrats were absent for the vote.
Hegseth has resisted calls for resignation. In a five‑minute video posted two days after the midterms, he dismissed critics as “deep‑state radicals” and declared that he would not back down. He urged the military to “stay the course,” including in the war against Iran, stating, “We are more determined than ever, more resolute than ever to finish what we have started.”
Criticism has also come from within his own party. Vice President JD Vance said the “real reason” Republicans lost the midterms was “the war.” Former U.S. diplomat Hala Rharrit, who resigned before Trump’s second term, said Hegseth would have been critical in guiding some of the Iran war’s most divisive moments, including the Minab elementary school bombing on February 28, the first day of the conflict. She explained that Hegseth and other senior Department of Defense officials would have drawn up initial strike lists before advising Trump on final approval.
Congress has the constitutional authority to pull the emergency cord and stop fighting. Brian Finucane, a former legal adviser in the State Department, said the midterm results partly reflected backlash against the Trump administration’s expansive use of executive power and the lack of transparency in overseas military actions. The incoming Democrat‑led Congress has pledged to use its powers to check Trump’s war‑making authority and confront Hegseth over his policies.
Democratic Congressman Hakeem Jeffries, now in line to become the first Black speaker of the House, told supporters that Hegseth’s days were numbered and described himself as a “hard yes” on impeachment proceedings. Jasmine El‑Gamal, a former Pentagon Middle East adviser, cautioned that impeachment is only one constitutional accountability mechanism. She pointed to congressional investigations and the legislature’s “power of the purse” as additional avenues for reining in Hegseth and Trump. El‑Gamal noted that the November impeachment motion was not an acquittal nor a vote resolving allegations of war crimes in Iran and elsewhere, and she expects the new Congress to continue pursuing those allegations.
Frequently asked questions
When was Pete Hegseth sworn in as Secretary of Defense?
He was sworn in on January 25, 2025.
What was the outcome of the impeachment vote?
The impeachment motion was blocked on November 10 with a 211‑204 vote, with eleven Democrats absent.
What actions did Hegseth take after the midterm elections?
He posted a five‑minute video two days after the midterms, dismissing critics as “deep‑state radicals” and urging the military to “stay the course” in the war against Iran.