Politics

Netanyahu Faces Legal and Political Turmoil Amid Post‑Election Controversy

By

Netanyahu Faces Legal and Political Turmoil Amid Post‑Election Controversy
Photo: The chief of the Israel Security Agency, Shin Bet, David Zini, participates in a state memorial ceremony in Mount Herzl, west Jerusalem [Olivier Fitoussi/Reuters]

Israel’s caretaker Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has used the weeks since the October 27 election to launch a series of attacks on his opponents and to question the legitimacy of the vote’s result. The longtime leader is likely on his way out of power, provided the opposition, led by Gadi Eisenkot, can form a viable government that may involve parties representing Palestinian citizens of Israel. Netanyahu has used this opportunity to tarnish the reputations of the Arab parties, baselessly accusing them of cheating in the elections. The environment he has helped create has led to right‑wing protesters threatening civil war, and critics have accused him of deliberately fomenting war with Iran to retain office.

Separately, the Shin Bet domestic intelligence agency, headed by Netanyahu’s ally David Zini, reportedly sought permission to tap the phones of five Arab lawmakers over suspected foreign interference and to have politicians who are Palestinian citizens of Israel arrested on election day. The attorney general rejected those requests. Opposition leaders, including Yair Lapid and Joint List chief Yousef Jabareen, said the measures were evidence of an “attempted coup.” Law enforcement officials are investigating whether the prime minister’s office fabricated allegations of vote‑buying.

For analysts and many Israeli politicians, Netanyahu’s actions reflect an overriding determination to stay in power or, failing that, to engineer a government that relies on his support. He faces numerous threats to his legacy and even his freedom, which, without the influence he has wielded as prime minister, could prove far‑reaching. Calls for a state inquiry into Netanyahu and his government’s failings in the run‑up to the Hamas‑led October 7, 2023 attack on Israel have persisted for almost as long as the war Israel launched on Gaza in response. Those calls have grown more urgent following reports that Netanyahu had been personally warned by senior Egyptian and Emirati officials about a potential attack.

Establishing a state inquiry also featured prominently on the legislative slate of the parliament’s new session last week. The war in Gaza and the constitutional crisis triggered by Netanyahu’s attempts to weaken judicial oversight have provided cover against the corruption charges he has faced since 2019. Accused of bribery, fraud and breach of trust in three separate cases, Netanyahu’s trial, running since May 2020, has been repeatedly delayed by his duties as prime minister. If found guilty, he could face a prison sentence of up to a decade.

Israeli analyst Ahron Bregman of King’s College London described Netanyahu as behaving like a wounded animal, noting that for him losing the elections is not just a political but also a personal matter, given the potential jail time. The risk of political violence has increased. Right‑wing protesters gathered outside Eisenkot’s home after the election, warning him not to form a government with Arab‑led parties and calling him a “traitor.” A letter from former Haifa rabbinical court head Rabbi Gedalia Axelrod invoked the religious edict of din rodef, the “law of the pursuer,” a principle used by Yigal Amir to justify the 1995 killing of former Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin.

Ofer Cassif, a member of parliament for the left‑wing Hadash party, said the longer it takes for Eisenkot to form a government, the higher the risk of political violence becomes. He warned that Netanyahu is willing to do anything to stay in power and that the right‑wing rhetoric about civil war could materialize. It remains unclear what immediate legal consequences Netanyahu may face for his alleged efforts to undermine the legitimacy of the election. Aides accused of passing false information to the police on the eve of the election could face criminal scrutiny, while Shin Bet chief Zini could see his agency’s independence and his own position undermined by alleged participation in efforts to subvert the democratic process.

Yossi Mekelberg, a senior consulting fellow at Chatham House, said Netanyahu battles for his survival and does not care if those around him disappear into oblivion. He added that Netanyahu’s focus is on survival and fighting for the next day, no matter the cost.

Frequently asked questions

Who is the caretaker Prime Minister of Israel after the Oct 27 election?

Benjamin Netanyahu.

What did the Shin Bet request regarding Arab lawmakers, and what was the outcome?

They sought permission to tap the phones of five Arab lawmakers and arrest Palestinian‑citizen politicians; the attorney general rejected those requests.

What are the potential legal consequences for Netanyahu if found guilty in his corruption cases?

He could face a prison sentence of up to a decade.

Related stories