Law & Justice

Supreme Court Demands Centre’s Action on Delayed Judges’ Appointment Procedure

By

Supreme Court Demands Centre’s Action on Delayed Judges’ Appointment Procedure
Photo: The MoP is a set of documents governing the appointment, elevation and transfer of high court and Supreme Court judges. (Sonu Mehta/HT PHOTO)

The Supreme Court on Wednesday asked the Centre and the Secretary‑General of the Court for a response to a petition that seeks finalisation of an amended Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) for appointing judges to the constitutional courts. The MoP governs the appointment, elevation and transfer of High Court and Supreme Court judges. A bench of Justices M.M. Sundresh and P.B. Varale issued notice on a petition filed by the NGO Lok Prahari, which questioned the delay in finalising the MoP despite a clear direction by a Constitution Bench in 2015 that struck down the National Judicial Appointments Commission and revived the Collegium system for appointing judges to the Supreme Court and High Courts.

After the 2015 judgment, an order was issued on 16 December 2025 directing the Centre to finalise the existing MoP by supplementing it with decisions taken by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant based on the unanimous view of the Collegium of the four senior‑most judges of the Court. The petition also seeks the minutes of the selection process conducted by the Collegium under the Right to Information (RTI) Act.

Advocate Shashank Singh, who filed the petition, stated that the existing MoP suffers from serious flaws of lack of transparency and objectivity, affecting the quality and performance of judges and thereby the litigants’ right to justice. The petition names the Union of India and the CJI through the Secretary‑General as respondents, as the 2015 order required the CJI to decide on the MoP based on the Collegium’s unanimous view.

The petition argues that ten years was more than enough to comply with the Constitution Bench’s decision, and that the implementation has been unduly delayed for no valid reason, constituting a persistent breach of duty by the Centre. It urges the Court to direct finalisation of the MoP within a month and to ensure transparency and objectivity in the selection process by making the Collegium meeting minutes available to the public under the RTI Act.

Frequently asked questions

What action has the Supreme Court requested from the Centre regarding the judges’ appointment procedure?

The Supreme Court asked the Centre to finalise the amended Memorandum of Procedure for appointing judges, supplementing it with decisions taken by the Chief Justice of India based on the Collegium’s unanimous view, and to provide the selection process minutes under the Right to Information Act.

Who filed the petition and what are the main concerns raised?

The petition was filed by the NGO Lok Prahari, represented by Advocate Shashank Singh. It raises concerns about the delay in finalising the MoP, lack of transparency and objectivity in the selection process, and the impact on litigants’ right to justice.

What did the 2015 Constitution Bench decision entail regarding judicial appointments?

The 2015 Constitution Bench struck down the National Judicial Appointments Commission and revived the Collegium system for appointing judges to the Supreme Court and High Courts.

Related stories