India

NHAI Cites Legal and Financial Limits in Supreme Court Over Highway Animal Removal

By

NHAI Cites Legal and Financial Limits in Supreme Court Over Highway Animal Removal

The National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) told the Supreme Court that it lacks the legal authority and financial resources to remove stray cattle and other animals from highways, a task that could cost more than ₹5,000 crore. During a hearing on 17 November, Solicitor‑General Tushar Mehta, representing NHAI, asked the Court to reconsider its November 2025 directions. He argued that the authority’s existing legal framework does not permit it to capture stray animals, relocate them to shelters, and arrange their rehabilitation, and that state governments are better positioned to handle the task because they have access to contingency funds.

The Bench of Justices Vikram Nath, Sandeep Mehta and N.V. Anjaria questioned how NHAI used toll revenue and emphasized that preventing accidents caused by stray animals is a matter of public safety. The judges suggested that NHAI could play a limited role, such as setting up animal shelters near toll plazas or in individual districts, but did not agree that the authority could not contribute to the effort. The Bench reserved its order on NHAI’s request and indicated it was not inclined to change its earlier directions.

The dispute stems from a set of directions issued in November 2025 that require NHAI, state governments and union territories to remove stray cattle and other animals from highways, move them to suitable shelters, gaushalas or cattle pounds, and provide food, water and veterinary care. The Court also called for dedicated highway patrol teams to monitor roads around the clock, display helpline numbers for commuters to report stray animals and related accidents, and extend the directive to remove stray dogs from schools, hospitals, sports complexes, bus stands, railway stations and other public facilities.

Senior advocate Gaurav Agrawal, assisting the Bench as amicus curiae, noted gaps in state implementation, such as designating existing veterinary institutions as shelters without establishing separate facilities or providing additional staff. The Court questioned whether such arrangements would be sufficient, stressing that naming an institution as a shelter would not solve the problem without adequate manpower.

States and union territories have also been directed to secure schools, colleges, hospitals and public transport facilities with boundary walls, appoint nodal officers and arrange regular inspections. The Supreme Court is expected to issue orders on NHAI’s application after considering its request and the compliance reports submitted by the states.

Frequently asked questions

Why does NHAI claim it cannot remove stray animals from highways?

NHAI says its legal framework does not allow it to capture stray animals, relocate them to shelters, and arrange rehabilitation, and it lacks financial resources.

What role did the Supreme Court suggest for NHAI?

The Court suggested NHAI could set up animal shelters near toll plazas or in districts but did not agree that it could not contribute to the effort.

Related stories