Law & Justice
ITAT Mumbai Removes Rs 14.25 Lakh Tax Addition Against Thane Flat Buyer

A man who bought a flat in Thane with his wife for Rs 72 lakh in April 2012 had a Rs 14.25 lakh addition to his taxable income deleted by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in Mumbai. The addition had been imposed by the Income Tax Department after it alleged that the taxpayer had paid extra cash for the property. The department cited material from the developer’s Gmail and Yahoo accounts and an Excel sheet that supposedly listed cash payments, as well as statements from the developer’s sales head and a promoter. It claimed the taxpayer had paid Rs 28.5 lakh in cash during 2011‑12, and treated half of that amount as unexplained money. The taxpayer, represented by a lawyer, argued that the flat was purchased for Rs 72 lakh and that all payments were recorded in the transaction documents and the registered agreement dated 4 April 2012. He also produced a builder’s confirmation acknowledging receipt of Rs 72 lakh. He challenged the use of third‑party statements without an opportunity to cross‑examine the witnesses. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld the addition and denied the request for cross‑examination, leading to an appeal before the ITAT. The ITAT bench found that the addition was largely based on statements from the developer and on electronic material that had not been submitted as part of the case records or provided to the taxpayer. It noted that the Gmail and Yahoo records cited by the department were not produced during the assessment proceedings. The tribunal observed that the builder’s confirmation was not considered by the assessing officer or the lower authority. It also held that statements from third parties cannot be taken as evidence unless they are tested by cross‑examination. The tribunal referred to earlier ITAT decisions in similar cases where additions based on uncorroborated statements were deleted. Concluding that the assessing officer had failed to substantiate the alleged payment with credible evidence, the ITAT deleted the Rs 14.25 lakh addition. Tax experts say the ruling could influence other disputes involving alleged ‘on‑money’ payments in real‑estate transactions, emphasizing the need for the department to provide independently verifiable evidence before imposing such additions.
Frequently asked questions
How much tax addition was removed by ITAT?
Rs 14.25 lakh.
What evidence did the Income Tax Department use to impose the addition?
They cited developer Gmail and Yahoo accounts, an Excel sheet listing cash payments, statements from the developer’s sales head and a promoter, claiming the taxpayer paid Rs 28.5 lakh in cash during 2011‑12 and treating half as unexplained.
Why did ITAT delete the tax addition?
ITAT found the addition was largely based on unverified third‑party statements and electronic material not submitted in the case records, and that the builder’s confirmation was not considered by the assessing officer, so the addition was deleted.