Law & Justice
Vermont Supreme Court Upholds $27,600 in Damages from Pond‑Construction Dispute

A land sale in 2015 turned into a complex legal fight over an unfinished pond, timber removal, unpaid work and an alleged assault. Gregory Lamson sold 42 acres in Royalton, Vermont, to James Goode. After the sale, Goode hired Lamson to build a pond on another property he owned. Lamson subcontracted Chase Locke to clear-cut land for the pond and also hired Locke to cut timber on his own land. Disagreements over payments, the pond’s completion and equipment use led Lamson to file suit in 2017 against Goode and Locke. Lamson accused Goode of breaching their construction agreement and of preventing him from finishing the pond, while he alleged that Goode had wrongfully used his tractor and other equipment. Against Locke, Lamson claimed breach of contract and conversion, saying Locke had sold timber and firewood from his property.
Goode counter‑claimed assault, and Locke counter‑claimed that Lamson had failed to pay him for logging work and had threatened false police reports to obtain money and property.
A jury awarded Lamson $7,500 for breach of contract, plus $8,149.32 in prejudgment interest. Goode received $5,000 for assault, and Locke was awarded $15,100 for civil extortion. The extortion claim was based on Lamson’s repeated threats to report Locke to the police and his parole officer unless Locke handed over money and property, including a storage locker.
Both Lamson and Goode sought attorney’s fees under Vermont’s Prompt Pay Act, but the trial court denied the requests, finding neither party had achieved a decisive victory.
On November 13, 2026, the Vermont Supreme Court affirmed the lower court’s judgment in its entirety. The court upheld all monetary awards, denied both parties’ requests for attorney’s fees, and left the civil extortion award intact without ruling on whether Vermont law recognizes a separate civil cause of action for extortion. The decision was published on Justia.
The Supreme Court held that the trial court had discretion to decide whether a party substantially prevailed for Prompt Pay Act fee purposes and found that neither Lamson nor Goode met that threshold. It also noted that Lamson had failed to preserve his challenge to the extortion damages through a timely post‑trial motion and had not ordered a transcript of the relevant testimony. The court’s ruling affirmed the $15,100 extortion award, the $7,500 breach‑of‑contract award, and the $5,000 assault award, and denied both parties’ fee claims.
Frequently asked questions
What was the total amount of damages upheld by the Vermont Supreme Court in the pond‑construction dispute?
The court upheld a total of $27,600 in damages, including $7,500 for breach of contract, $5,000 for assault, and $15,100 for civil extortion.
Did the Vermont Supreme Court award attorney’s fees to either party under the Prompt Pay Act?
No, the court denied both Gregory Lamson’s and James Goode’s requests for attorney’s fees, finding neither party substantially prevailed.
What was the outcome of the civil extortion claim against Chase Locke?
The court affirmed the $15,100 civil extortion award to Locke and left the award intact without ruling on a separate civil cause of action for extortion under Vermont law.