India

Government Plans to Scrutinize Product Claims on Packaging

By

Government Plans to Scrutinize Product Claims on Packaging

New Delhi – The consumer affairs ministry is developing a plan to examine front‑of‑pack trademarks and claims on food, cosmetics and other consumer goods. If companies cannot substantiate their claims with credible evidence, the ministry may recommend delisting the products. The Department of Consumer Affairs says it is reviewing these labels because consumers often rely on them when making purchase decisions. The Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) has already found cases where claims were not supported by the products’ actual composition or performance. It is writing to the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) to explore mechanisms for scrutinizing such trademarks and ensuring that claims are backed by evidence. The CCPA will also consult stakeholders and ask companies to correct their labels. Where products are found inconsistent with their packaging claims, the authority will recommend delisting and take other necessary action. The CCPA has the power to investigate and impose penalties, as it did in June when it fined Storia Foods and Mrs. Bectors Food Specialities ₹1 lakh each for misleading front‑of‑pack claims on tender coconut water and whole‑wheat bread. Section 9(2)(a) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, prohibits registration of deceptive marks, while Section 57 allows cancellation or rectification of registered trademarks. The plan comes amid increasing regulatory scrutiny over product descriptions, labeling and advertising claims. Manufacturers such as ITC, Dabur India and AWL Agri Business have challenged Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) actions in court over claims like ‘100% Pure’, ‘100% Natural’ and ‘100% Organic’. The Delhi High Court has sought responses from the Centre and FSSAI in cases involving claims such as ‘100% Veg’ and ‘Cholesterol Free – For Healthy Lifestyle’. These cases are pending and do not constitute final judgments that the claims were misleading. In the Storia case, the CCPA found that the ‘100% Tender Coconut Water’ product was made by reconstituting coconut water concentrate with water, and the qualification appeared only in the ingredients panel. In the Mrs. Bectors case, the authority examined claims such as ‘100% Atta Bread’ and ‘100% Whole Wheat Bread’, noting that ‘100%’ is an absolute numerical claim that must accurately reflect the product’s composition. Queries sent to the consumer affairs department and major FMCG firms on 13 November remain unanswered. Consumer VOICE’s managing trustee Ashim Sanyal said that any gap between packaging claims and a product’s actual composition or performance can mislead consumers, especially when they pay a premium. Legal experts Vijay Kumar of Fox Mandal and others say the new scrutiny layer will increase compliance obligations, requiring companies to ensure all claims are supported by scientific evidence and can withstand regulatory examination.

Frequently asked questions

What is the new plan by the consumer affairs ministry?

The ministry is developing a plan to examine front‑of‑pack trademarks and claims on food, cosmetics and other consumer goods, recommending delisting if claims lack credible evidence.

Which companies were fined by the CCPA for misleading claims?

Storia Foods and Mrs. Bectors Food Specialities were fined ₹1 lakh each for misleading front‑of‑pack claims on tender coconut water and whole‑wheat bread.

What legal provisions are cited regarding deceptive trademarks?

Section 9(2)(a) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 prohibits registration of deceptive marks, while Section 57 allows cancellation or rectification of registered trademarks.

Related stories