Politics

Auckland Mayor Criticises MMP After China Trip

By

Auckland Mayor Criticises MMP After China Trip
Photo: Caption: Auckland mayor Wayne Brown is a fan of the way China does business. Photo credit: RNZ / Marika Khabazi

Auckland mayor Wayne Brown said New Zealand’s mixed‑member proportional (MMP) electoral system is not working and that the country should consider a different approach. Brown made the comments to Stuff after returning from a six‑city business tour of China. The visit coincided with the general election in which the National Party won the most seats because of an overhang, while Labour received the larger share of party votes.

Brown described the system as “unfathomable” and compared it to the United States, where he said the election produced a “non‑working government.” He added that Europe had not held a good election for years and that “democracy’s had its day.”

He praised China’s economic model, noting that it allows businesses to fail, whereas in New Zealand they can be propped up, citing Fletcher Building as an example. On the Morning Report he supported Christopher Luxon’s suggestion that a referendum on MMP be held. Brown said that when the National leader floated the idea earlier this year, coalition partners ACT and New Zealand First “jumped on” it because they can enter Parliament without winning an electorate seat. He added that “our Parliament is full of people who’ve been rejected by the locals.”

Brown said the current version of MMP has not produced a clear result and that after weeks of political coverage “we still don’t know who’s winning.” He did not call for a Communist system but said it would be “nice to have the results of China.” He noted that China has transformed from a backward peasant society in the last 40 years, while New Zealand has slipped from being a top‑five economy, with National and Labour “presiding over the decline of the country.”

He also said the government has not done enough to build a relationship with China, pointing out that China is becoming food self‑sufficient and growing more kiwifruit and milk than New Zealand. Brown said there were a few things China has achieved that would be “enormous” for Auckland, but he could not share details.

The main purpose of the trip was to attend the China International Import Expo in Shanghai, where Brown was the main speaker at the Global Mayors Forum in Ningbo City. He said the visit was an opportunity to learn about China’s traffic systems and to consider camera‑based systems for Auckland, as opposed to the city’s current random time‑based system.

Brown accused the last coalition government of backtracking on a deal it had made with Auckland, which he said led to a drop in voter support. He said people dislike backtracking and prefer plain talking and sticking to what has been promised.

Aucklanders are currently being consulted on three forms of congestion charging. Brown said the plans need to go ahead to ease the city’s congestion, adding that “we’re gonna have it.” He noted that time‑of‑use charging has been a runaway success in countries that have adopted it.

Frequently asked questions

What did Wayne Brown say about New Zealand's MMP system?

He said the mixed‑member proportional (MMP) electoral system is not working and that the country should consider a different approach.

What was the main purpose of Wayne Brown's trip to China?

The trip was to attend the China International Import Expo in Shanghai and he was the main speaker at the Global Mayors Forum in Ningbo City.

Did Wayne Brown call for a Communist system?

He did not call for a Communist system but said it would be nice to have the results of China.

Related stories