India
Chandigarh Consumer Commission Orders ₹31,000 Compensation After Jacket Tear Found Within 46 Minutes
By Sneha Biswas

A Chandigarh consumer commission ruled in favor of a man who discovered a tear beneath the arm of a newly purchased jacket within 46 minutes. The commission directed the retailer to pay ₹31,000 to the customer, who had been refused assistance by the store. According to Indian Express, the commission found that the store failed to prove the damage was caused by the customer’s mishandling and did not conduct an independent inspection or expert opinion. The order was granted on November 4. The commission, headed by President Amrinder Singh Sidhu and member Brij Mohan Shama, noted that the retailer could not rely solely on its internal assessment to reject the complaint. The retailer had not explained its findings or submitted technical evidence to prove the customer’s alleged mishandling. The store claimed the customer had inspected the jacket, which cost ₹10,999, before purchase. The commission rejected this claim, pointing out that the tear was in an inconspicuous area that would not have been detected during a normal check. “The principle of ‘Buyer Beware’ does not apply to consumers because the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 is a benevolent and welfare Act,” the commission observed, as quoted by the outlet. The customer bought three jackets from a store in a Chandigarh mall on December 25, 2025. One jacket, costing ₹10,999, had a tear that was noticed on January 1, 2026, within 46 minutes of wearing it. The customer emailed the store on January 10 and requested details and documents the next day. The retailer initially said the complaint had been escalated for review on January 12 but later rejected the claim after two days, stating the damage was from the customer’s actions rather than a manufacturing defect. The customer said the store did not conduct a physical inspection in his presence or provide photographs, a technical assessment, or any supporting evidence. After repeated follow‑ups and an unanswered legal notice dated January 15, the customer approached the consumer commission seeking a replacement or refund, along with compensation for harassment and litigation costs. The store maintained that the customer had inspected and tried the jacket at purchase and had initially approached the store for repairs, claiming the damage was his fault. The commission found the retailer guilty of deficient service and unfair trade practice, directing it to refund ₹11,000 for the jacket and pay an additional ₹20,000 as compensation for harassment and litigation expenses.
Frequently asked questions
What compensation did the Chandigarh consumer commission award?
The commission ordered the retailer to pay ₹31,000 to the customer, comprising a ₹11,000 refund and ₹20,000 compensation.
How soon after wearing the jacket did the customer notice the tear?
The customer noticed the tear within 46 minutes of wearing the jacket.
What was the price of the jacket that had the tear?
The jacket that had the tear cost ₹10,999.