Law & Justice
High Court Upholds £1 Million Legal Bill for 95‑Year‑Old Widow in Kent Garden Dispute

A 95‑year‑old widow in Sissinghurst, near Tunbridge Wells, will have to pay more than £1 million in legal costs after the High Court rejected her appeal against a costs order. Mary Egan had argued that she had largely won the original case over a 45‑square‑metre strip of garden land and should not be responsible for the expenses. Mr Justice Tappin dismissed the appeal, leaving the earlier decision that each party pay its own costs unchanged.
The dispute involved businessman Neil Morgan, 65, and his wife Fiona, 61, who live next door to Egan. It centred on a boundary of about 60 metres that included grass, trees and scrub. The conflict began in 2015 when the Morgans installed a new fence between their property and Egan’s land. Egan’s lawyers claimed the couple had entered her property, removed the existing wooden fence and erected new structures on her side of the boundary. After Egan removed one of the fences, the Morgans built another and sued her for the cost of the damaged fence. Egan counter‑claimed for trespassing and sought a boundary line through the middle of a line of trees and hedges.
In 2021, at a trial in Maidstone County Court, Recorder John Dagnall rejected the Morgans’ claim over the damaged fence and found that they had trespassed by installing the structures. Egan was awarded £2,600 in damages, but the judge refused to order the removal of the third fence, allowing it to remain as the new boundary and awarding her an additional £3,250 in damages.
In 2024, Recorder Dagnall ordered both parties to bear their own legal expenses, describing the outcome as a “score draw.” The Morgans had incurred six‑figure costs but represented themselves for much of the later proceedings. Egan retained lawyers throughout, resulting in a bill exceeding £1 million. Her barrister, Daniel Petrides, argued that because the Morgans’ claim had been dismissed and the court recognised their trespass, the Morgans should pay Egan’s expenses. He also cited Morgan’s offensive remarks toward judges, lawyers and court staff, including a comment that one judge was “not fit to judge vegetables at a village fete.” Morgan, who represented himself and his wife during the appeal, disputed this interpretation and claimed that the central issue was the boundary location.
Mr Justice Tappin acknowledged that Morgan’s language toward opposing lawyers, their staff and court officials was unacceptable but found no basis to overturn the original judge’s assessment of how that behaviour should affect the allocation of costs. He also upheld the earlier decision that Egan had failed to establish that the boundary ran through the middle of the hedge, a key part of her case. The judge noted the disproportionate resources spent on a strip of land with little practical or financial value, describing the case as an “expenditure of time, cost and energy wholly out of proportion to the financial value of the area of land in dispute.” The neighbours had been involved in litigation over the 45‑square‑metre strip since 2016, with Egan claiming legal expenses of more than £1 million.