Law & Justice

Delhi High Court Rules Corporate Guarantees Subject to GST Even When Free, 1% Valuation Not Mandatory

By

Delhi High Court Rules Corporate Guarantees Subject to GST Even When Free, 1% Valuation Not Mandatory

New Delhi – The Delhi High Court held that a parent company providing a free guarantee for a subsidiary’s loan is still supplying a taxable service under GST law. The bench, comprising Justices Anil Khetarpal and Bharat Parashar, ruled that the guarantee is a service even if no fee is charged, because the parent assumes responsibility for the loan if the subsidiary defaults. The guarantee also enables the subsidiary to draw on the parent’s creditworthiness, making the subsidiary the beneficiary of the service.

The court clarified that the government’s rule fixing the taxable value of a guarantee at 1 % of the loan amount is not a compulsory minimum. Companies can prove that the actual value of a guarantee is lower, and GST must be calculated on that lower value. The court also specified when tax becomes payable: GST applies when the guarantee is issued, not each year it remains in force. A renewal, extension or enhancement of the guarantee constitutes a new service and attracts GST again. Invocation of the guarantee after a default does not trigger additional tax.

The ruling distinguishes guarantees issued in three periods. Guarantees issued before 1 July 2017 are not liable to GST unless renewed, extended or enhanced. Guarantees issued between 1 July 2017 and 25 October 2023 may attract GST, but the 1 % valuation rule does not apply. The rule applies to guarantees executed, renewed, extended or enhanced from 26 October 2023.

The court set aside tax notices, orders and demands that ran contrary to its findings for companies such as Sterlite Power Transmission, ReNew, GAIL India, Avaada Energy, Hero Future Energies and Hero Solar Energy. Tax authorities may now reassess liability and issue fresh notices in accordance with the ruling, after giving companies an opportunity to be heard.

Experts say the decision will prompt companies to review corporate guarantee arrangements, particularly input tax credit eligibility and valuation. "The focus should be on proper documentation, valuation and checking ITC eligibility rather than mechanically applying the 1 % rate," said Ankit Jain, partner at Ved Jain and Associates. Jigar Doshi, country head of indirect tax practice at Ascentium India, added that every execution, renewal, extension or enhancement is now a taxable event.

The ruling is likely to affect companies in power, infrastructure, renewable energy, telecom and roads, where parent companies frequently guarantee loans raised by special purpose vehicles. The government introduced the 1 % valuation rule in a notification dated 26 October 2023, following a GST Council meeting on 7 October 2023. Sterlite Power Transmission, the lead petitioner, challenged both the rule and the government’s circulars. The Delhi High Court upheld the government’s power to introduce the valuation rule but clarified that the 1 % benchmark is a rebuttable presumption, not a fixed minimum.

A similar judgment by the Gujarat High Court in August upheld GST on corporate guarantees but held that the 1 % rule could not be applied to guarantees issued before 26 October 2023. The Delhi High Court’s decision is now being watched by the Supreme Court, which on 16 November 2026 admitted a petition against the Gujarat High Court’s decision and granted a stay of the demand.

Frequently asked questions

When does GST become payable on a corporate guarantee?

GST applies when the guarantee is issued; it is not payable each year it remains in force. A renewal, extension or enhancement of the guarantee is a new taxable event.

Is the 1% of loan amount valuation rule mandatory for all guarantees?

No. The 1% rule is a rebuttable presumption; companies can prove a lower value and GST will be calculated on that lower value.

Does invoking a guarantee after a default trigger additional GST?

No. Invocation of the guarantee after a default does not trigger additional tax.

Related stories