Politics

Baroness Cass Expresses Concerns Over Draft Conversion Practices Bill

By

Baroness Cass Expresses Concerns Over Draft Conversion Practices Bill

Baroness Cass, the author of an independent review on gender identity services for young people, said she does not support the current draft bill banning conversion practices, despite having welcomed it earlier. Speaking at a parliamentary committee reviewing the bill, she warned that the wording could lead to serious unintended consequences for parents of children with gender distress and for medical professionals working in the field.

The government says the bill will protect LGBT people in England and Wales. A spokesperson welcomed Cass’s comments and said the government would take all evidence from the committee seriously as it "wants to get this ban right".

Conversion practices are defined as interventions, treatments or activities designed to change or suppress a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity. They can occur in religious or family settings and are often distressing to the individual. The UK has long campaigned to outlaw such practices, and Labour promised to introduce a ban in its 2024 manifesto.

When the government released its draft legislation in June, Cass was quoted in the publicity as saying she was pleased to see clearer definitions of what constitutes a conversion practice and what does not. She also said she looked forward to further scrutiny before the bill became law. However, when asked at the committee whether she supported the bill in its current form, she answered simply "no".

Cass said the increased polarisation around gender could lead to misuse of the new law. The current wording requires the victim to suffer "serious harm to the individual's physical or mental health, or serious alarm or distress to the individual which has a substantial adverse effect on their usual day‑to‑day activities." She warned that this could allow "vexatious" complaints that might put therapists working with young gender‑distressed people at risk of prosecution. For example, a therapist discussing a young person’s sexual abuse could be restricted from therapeutic work if the discussion is deemed to trigger the individual.

She also raised concerns about the impact on families. If a parent stops a child from buying a breast binder or hormones, that action could fall within the scope of the bill and lead to prosecution.

When asked about her earlier support for the bill, Cass said she had been in favour of the idea but had not had time to read the details before the press release was published, yet she still gave the quote. In her 2024 report on gender identity services, she described conversion practices as "abhorrent" and reiterated that no LGBT person should be subjected to them. She told the committee she wants a bill that protects the people it is meant to protect without unintentionally entrap­ing others.

The government reiterated that it wants to "get this ban right" and will consider all evidence from the committee as it moves forward in ending the decade‑long delay in protecting LGBT+ people from abusive conversion practices. The committee hearings continue.

Frequently asked questions

What is Baroness Cass's position on the draft conversion practices bill?

She does not support the bill in its current form, though she had earlier welcomed it.

What concerns did Baroness Cass raise about the bill's wording?

She warned that the wording could lead to serious unintended consequences for parents and medical professionals, potentially allowing vexatious complaints that could prosecute therapists or parents for actions like stopping a child from buying a binder or hormones.

What does the government say the bill will achieve?

The government says the bill will protect LGBT people in England and Wales.

Related stories