Politics

Supreme Court Rejects Claim That Voters or Candidates Can Demand SC/ST Reservation in Constituency

By

Supreme Court Rejects Claim That Voters or Candidates Can Demand SC/ST Reservation in Constituency

The Supreme Court on Monday ruled that no voter or candidate has a right to demand that a particular constituency be reserved for the Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes. The Court held that the government’s decision to reserve a constituency cannot be challenged if the number of reserved seats is proportionate to the population of these communities. The ruling came after petitioners challenged a 2025 amendment to the Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis Act, 1961, which stated that the next general election would be the starting point for rotating constituencies reserved for SC/ST communities. The petitioners argued that the amendment erased the history of previous rotations and would prevent some constituencies that should have been reserved based on the earlier cycle from being reserved. Advocate Vipin Sanghi said that introducing new rules alone does not justify disregarding the previous rotation cycle where relevant electoral territories continue to exist, even if boundaries or designations change. A bench of Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana asked whether voters or candidates have a right to get a constituency reserved for the SC/ST community and answered that no. The Court stated that the rules require the number of seats reserved for the SC/ST community to be proportionate to their population in the state or democratic unit that will go to polls, and that the required percentage of seats has been reserved. The bench refused to entertain the petition and said the amended rules complied with the constitutionally mandated reservation policy, but allowed the petitioners to submit their representations to the appropriate authority.

Frequently asked questions

Can voters or candidates demand a constituency be reserved for SC/ST?

No, Supreme Court ruled that no voter or candidate has that right.

What criteria must be met for a constituency to be reserved for SC/ST?

The number of reserved seats must be proportionate to the population of SC/ST communities in the state or democratic unit that will go to polls.

What was the issue with the 2025 amendment to the Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis Act?

Petitioners argued the amendment erased the history of previous rotations and would prevent some constituencies that should have been reserved based on earlier cycle from being reserved.

Related stories